Eheim Surface Protein Extractor (Skimmer)

[carver]

Does anyone have recent experience with the Eheim Surface Skimmer? I have seen at least one post in the archives that was negative about it. (Maybe they haven't changed??) I have an Eheim Filter and would like to add the surface skimmer. ( I know the majority of you are death on Canister filters but I come from the old school and have always had good luck with it) This is for my 46 gal bow front. Thanks for any help.

 

[SeaMac]

If you are going to give one of these devices a try, I would go with the one made by Fluval. It is similar in design, but only costs $9.99 (That Fish Place).

I think there were a few threads about these in the "Nano Reefs" forum at Reef Central. You might want to do a search over there for more info. I think the poster was Lunchbucket.

Chris

 

[carver]

Thanks for the reference. $9.99 would sure beat the 30.00 Enheim. I am might try making one from plans that I found on a different site. This is only a temporary fix until I put a sump system under this tank.

 

[fish esq.]

I used to use one on my planted FW aquarium with good results, but I no longer keep FW tanks. However, the skimmer performance depends on the water level of the tank (narrow range of effectiveness); if it is outside the optimum range, then its worthless.

Also, it does make gurgling noises, which can be minimized/elminated with adjustment.

Definitely keeps the surface clean, but pricey.

 

[carver]

Thanks for your input, it seems to confirm what I have been hearing. The Eheim surface extractor is not worth the price. I have pretty much cleared up the surface film by redirecting the jets of my filter return and my powerheads. Again, this is only temporary until I can justify the cost of a sump. (with my wife!!) I had the Enheim canister from a previous 55 gal tank.