I found a new store on Rte 25 in Centerreach - I believe its called GnC Reef and Fish or something along those lines, the sign isnt up yet. It is attached to Grampz Motorcycle ( or Bikes but its a motorcycle shop ) and is opposite Diesel Reptiles. Its a one room shop with about 2 dozen tanks of fish and a couple of coral tanks ( sw stuff only ). I picked up some fish there at a good price. Many, but not all, of the prices are pretty competitive and the guy is willing to work with you. The tanks and fish appear well taken care of. I suggested he become a site vendor or sponsor but he wasnt sure it was worth it for him being out in Suffolk, so if you stop by let him know Eric from MR recommended him. ( Disclaimer: I am not affiliate with the store, nor do I get paid for this advertisement. I'm just trying to help a decent local shop get off the ground to improve our local selections ).