• Why not take a moment to introduce yourself to our members?

Jlavine

Advanced Reefer
Location
NYC
Rating - 100%
82   0   0
Please read through post as there are a few questions at the end and pictures. Thank you everyone for your help, Jeff


It's never good when your wife calls you crying and the first words out of her mouth are ...."your tank".... then silence.

She heard the tank (29g Cube) blowing air due to a low water level so she decided to fill it with the 1 gallon water jug under the tank. Well, it turns out the water jug was pre-mixed 2-part ALK. She poured 1500ml Alkalinity in at once and the tank instantly became chalky white!

As fate would have it, I set up a new frag tank (22x16x8) as a second tank only 2 days ago. She did well with guidance over the phone to first move all my frag plugs and ranks over and then any rocks with corals carefully to the new tank. It was all by feel as the tank was blinding white.

I luckily had a break at work at that moment and drove 30 minutes home. In 20 mins at home I moved the remaining rocks and all coral to the new tank. I did a 50% water change 5g at a time. EXTREMELY close call as if I didn't have this tank you can only imagine what would have been lost. By the time I got home, I unfortunately lost my six-line wrasse, 5 peppermint shrimp (bought yesterday and friday!), feather dusters and all my snails. Damn aptasia survived. The corals are doing well and my 5yr old clown that was lying on its side on the sand bed are doing OK. I'm sure there's going to be loss as the frag tank is super crowded (pics don't do justice), only 2 days old and lots of corals broke during the transfer.


Things I learned:
-This was my fault, not hers
-Teach those in your house a few basics about your tank or at least to call you before pouring liquids into the tank
-Label all containers well
-Install your top off that's been sitting in the box for 6 months
-If you can, have another tank for emergencies
-Crisis management and creating a new tank-scape may be stressfull and sad, but can also be fun (or challenging is a better word?)


What I'm doing now and questions:

1. I have since done multiple water changes and will continue to do so daily. Is this the best way to get my ALK down (above chart levels right now). I don't think adding calcium to have it drop will work well, especially with the water changes.

2. I removed all coral and rocks from the tank (except 2 large base rocks set well in the sand bed). During this move LOTS of debris/detritus/dirt/etc was disturbed and when settled created a large layer on top of my sand. I therefore siphoned this away and may have got carried away with the cleaning as I vacuumed deep into most of my sand bed (1.5").

Will this cause spikes and cycle the tank? Should I be testing the water daily or give it a few days as I'll be doing water changes anyway and nothing of life is in the tank?

3. Most of my base rocks that didn't have coral on them are now in a separate 10g tank that I bought today with a power head for flow. Do I need a heater or is room temp OK for the live rock for now?

4. Any other advice or things I should be thinking about during this time. I want to make sure everything is right before I add my livestock/corals back.

5. Stay tuned for a new tank thread...


Tanks on 4/11/14








Tanks 4/13/14



 
Last edited:

Jlavine

Advanced Reefer
Location
NYC
Rating - 100%
82   0   0
Thanks. I've done a full 50% change again tonight. My KH test goes up to 14 and I'm still over. How frequently and what quantity of changes would you continue? Since I have no livestock in the tank except a few rocks and sand, should I just change it all?
 

tunicata

Tunicate Tamer
Location
Brooklyn, NY
Rating - 100%
163   0   0
Oh, wow. Im sorry this happened. I am however, happy that you have such a thoughtful and rational response.

You are sticking with it, working hard and are not blaming . I look forward to meeting you for the snails
 
Location
Bronx
Rating - 100%
34   0   0
sorry to hear that bro just went through a similar problem only i lost everything your doing everything correct and your right about having a backup tank running i do now it just has a canister filter and when i change the water from my DT i use that to change the water in the Back up tank i think you will be okay you saved them before they went into shock
 

Jlavine

Advanced Reefer
Location
NYC
Rating - 100%
82   0   0
Few loses that I can see so far :(

2" strawberry shortcake
1" encrusted plug with lots of branches ready to take off Tricolor SPS
Tooth/Galaxea coral
2-3" double branch green slimmer
Green millipora frag
red/yellow favia frag
missing 4 poylps of red hornets! Only frag to just fall off the plug! My luck
Sunset monti frag
3 feather dusters
all snails
all shrimp (peppermint, coral banded)
emerald crab
multiple Zs & Ps still closed

Seems as if 1 arm of my banded starfish is falling off and the tips of his tenticles too.

Clownfish OK so far :)
 

Jlavine

Advanced Reefer
Location
NYC
Rating - 100%
82   0   0
What parameters (other than ALK), should I be closely watching during this time. What's the best way to monitor for a cycle or spike?
 

jackson6745

SPS KILLER
Location
NJ
Rating - 99%
201   2   0
I'm glad you can stay positive in a time of disaster, I would have filed for divorce ;)

I'm only playing. Sorry about this disaster.

My corrective measure would be a very larger water change 80%ish. You need to get water parameters correct ASAP before you have more losses.

Run lots of carbon

I would also dose a nitryifing bacteria additive such as Microb-lift Nite out II to promote bacterial stability, because you definitely killed off quite a bit with this mishap.

Best of luck man :(
 
Last edited:

Jlavine

Advanced Reefer
Location
NYC
Rating - 100%
82   0   0
Thanks for everyone's support through this. Now things are slowly looking iffy in my frag tank. I can certainly imagine how keeping parameters constant in a 12g tank (that's now 3 days old and has all the livestock from my 30 gallon) is extremely hard. Double worries and tanks to deal with now.

I do have Prodibio BioClean, should I try to dose that?

My goal is to start moving things back in the next few days as I've been attacking this pretty aggressively with water changes and general tank cleans (filter, skimmer, pumps, etc).
 

Jlavine

Advanced Reefer
Location
NYC
Rating - 100%
82   0   0
Thanks Dace. I have 1 frag of sunset monti left, so I'll nurse that one back for now. Once everything is back up and running I may take you up on the tricolor offer. I really appreciate it.
 

Jlavine

Advanced Reefer
Location
NYC
Rating - 100%
82   0   0
Took water in for testing yesterday. All values were OK, but ammonia was very high. I did a 75% water change since, added back some live rock and added beneficial bacteria. Any thoughts? (I don't have exact numbers).

Will take water for another complete test tomorrow and post results.

Thanks!
 

Sponsor Reefs

We're a FREE website, and we exist because of hobbyists like YOU who help us run this community.

Click here to sponsor $10:


Top