A
Anonymous
Guest
My experience is similar to Charles's. In a tank with uncured live rock it can't keep up with the decay. In a tank with just sand and water it worked fine. I even used something similar to "cycle" a 30 gallon with a couple of pairs of German Rams a few years ago and it worked flawlessly. My opinion was these kind of products simply let you avoid starting your tank with "sacrificial" fish you don't like (ie. zebra danios, comets, or damsels).
And FWIW, you may want to discuss your idea of "leasing" a yellow tang until it gets to big with your LFS. I don't know anyone in their right mind who would take in a yellow tang that had been kept in those kind of conditions for any kind of trade in value. Why would they when they can get a new for $5 wholesale?
And FWIW, you may want to discuss your idea of "leasing" a yellow tang until it gets to big with your LFS. I don't know anyone in their right mind who would take in a yellow tang that had been kept in those kind of conditions for any kind of trade in value. Why would they when they can get a new for $5 wholesale?