Exodin

[Tranquil201]

Has anyone used this product? If so can you let me know your results.

 

[Domboski]

I never used it but I was with someone from Germany (Advanced aquarist) and they said its an old product there and it is viewed as ineffective. Its just a new product in the US. Not quite the info you were looking for but hopefully helpful nonetheless.

 

[Tranquil201]

Thanks for the info. I have been using Herbtana for 8 days now and one of the LFS swears by exodin and keeps telling me to stop Herbtana and start using exodin.

 

[Domboski]

My personal feeling is that anything that is reef safe is not going to be 100% effective against ich. Its a band-aid. If Herbtana is working for you than there would be no reason to switch. My friend noted that Exodin has been around in Europe for years. If it was so effective it wouldn't be new here. Especially since the hobby has become global while still being a small world.

Do what you are most comfortable with and works best for you

 

[Tranquil201]

I'm not really sure if the Herbtana is working or not. I might just try to get them out and copper treat them. I am just afraid at this point they will get to stressed out and die from me trying to get them with the net.

 

[Domboski]

Netting fish should not be enough stress to kill them unless there is something really wrong with them. Ich should not be enough to make fish die from netting. I move fish with ich all of the time with no problems.