• Why not take a moment to introduce yourself to our members?

clarionreef

Advanced Reefer
Location
San Francisco
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Tuesday, 18 February, 2003, 18:11 GMT
'If we can't fish, we can't live'

Cod stocks in the North Sea are under threat

As fishermen prepare to protest against proposals to dramatically reduce cod fishing in the North Sea, Dennis Clark - who comes from six generations of fishermen - tells why he is joining them.

"The European Commission wants to cut the days we can fish by 80%. If they have their way, that will mean I can only go to sea for 50 days next year.
"The simple fact is, if we don't catch fish, we don't take home any money," he said.

Dennis left school to join a trawler when he was 14. He is now 50.

It's not just a few men who will be put out of business - it's entire communities



In the winter he gets up every morning two hours before dawn to reach the fishing grounds in the North Sea.

"Fishing was all I wanted to do, it was all I knew really. My dad and grandfather were fishermen. I had my own little boat when I was still at school and I used to go out lobster potting for pocket money.

"Now my son Peter works with me, my father who is 80 still lends a hand and my wife is the daughter of a fisherman. It is not just a few men who will be put out of business by these restrictions - it's entire communities."

Scientists say cod is facing extinction in the North Sea and have also called for drastic reductions in the amounts of other white fish, like haddock and whiting, being caught.

The fishermen simply do not believe the EC's figures.

'Still cod there'

"I think the scientific data is very weak," Dennis said.


Scientists say stocks will collapse in 12 months
"I've spoken to fishermen in the north of the North Sea and they have been catching big cod.

"The scientists took their samples from areas where we already know there are no cod. The situation is simply not as bad as they are making out."

Dennis thinks there are other less drastic measures that could be taken to save stocks.

A policy started two years ago to stop fishing in the spawning grounds seems to be paying off.

I love this life - there's a great sense of freedom and independence



He also thinks the government could have stepped in and like in farming, paid subsidies to large trawlers to lay off fishing for periods.

"Just four months a year for a couple of years would have turned cod stocks around immediately," he said.

"We're not against conservation but the cuts they are talking about will put us out of business."

Dennis fears, like many others, that he will be out of business by the proposed reduction in trawling.

'Last stand'

And at 50, he sees little hope of alternative employment.


Franz Fischler proposes drastic cuts
"I've said to my son he should think about doing something else. But he's young.

"I love this life. There's a great sense of freedom and independence. Out there we're our own bosses, but those skills aren't transferable."

Dennis, who lives in the little village of Cullercoats on North Tyneside, does not hold out much hope the demonstration will have much effect on the Commission's decision.

"Brussels is so big I suppose they will ignore us. But we all felt we had to take one last stand."

ps.
I just thought it was interesting to see a story when our own English speaking kind are the ones being downscaled for the sake of fishery management.
Steve
 

treeman

Experienced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
That has been happening in the US for many years.

Banning nets in Fl.

Banning most longlines on the eastcoast of US.

Banning fish traps in most/some of FL.

Limiting the amount of Lobster and crab traps available to reduce the take.

Reduce size and quantity of Snapper, Grouper, Snook and Redfish for the Commercial and Recreational fisheries.

That is just what I am aware of in Florida.
 

nanocat

Experienced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
...Scientists say stocks will collapse in 12 months

I'm inclined to think the fishermen could be right in that the scientific data might be flawed. Who in their right mind would wait until 12 months from the collapse of the entire fishery to do something? Something's "fishy" about this data :roll:
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
nanocat":2nv7ss57 said:
...Scientists say stocks will collapse in 12 months

I'm inclined to think the fishermen could be right in that the scientific data might be flawed. Who in their right mind would wait until 12 months from the collapse of the entire fishery to do something? Something's "fishy" about this data :roll:


what do you expect from data collectors that get paid scale ?



















<the evil punster strikes again!>
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
You mean environmental scientists make things look worse than they really are?

Shocking 8O :roll:
 

PeterIMA

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Having worked for several agencies where I did fisheries stock assessments, I take issue with the assertion that the scientific date were wrong or that the stock assessments were biased. In most cases, it is the fact that the fishing companies/industry control the councils and/or the political appointees on the councils have allowed the quotas to exceed the scientific advice.

Stock assessment models are not easy for non-scientists to understand. That does not make them wrong. As a scientist with the Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission, I can attest to the quality of the science behind the regulations cited here (bag limits, size limits, and other restrictions on fishing effort).

In the case of New England and eastern Canada, the situation is compounded by overfishing AND climate change. Still, if the councils had acted on the scientific advice, there might still be fisheries for cod, haddock, redfish, and other groundfish.

Peter Rubec
 

treeman

Experienced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
For the record Peter, I was not attacking you with the list of restrictions. I happen to agree with them. It sure seems like the science is accurate and the councils can't seem to enact the regulations that are needed to go with it. But, as you said the industry is in the middle of it most of the time.

I used to be a commercial fisherman and decided it was to much like work. So now I just fish for fun. The restrictions on Redfish along with, I guess, the net ban have really made them come back.
 

PeterIMA

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Treeman, Yes, Florida has done a good job managing red drum (redfish). The same cannot be said for Texas.

Peter
 

Sponsor Reefs

We're a FREE website, and we exist because of hobbyists like YOU who help us run this community.

Click here to sponsor $10:


Top