Using a skimmer part time?

[Wingnutt021]

I have a question for everyone. But first a little background...

I have a 10 gallon reef with an eclipse filter hood combo. I purchased the smallest protein skimmer i could find, but it was still VERY unsightly in the water. Recently, I've noticed a bit of an oil-slick looking film on the water surface. Nothing too bad, but it is present.

I was thinking of just throwing in the skimmer at night before I go to bed, and pulling it out in the morning. Some skimming is better than no skimming, right?

Let me know what you guys think. Thanks!

 

[Brian5000]

Skimming is never a bad idea, but remember to account for the fact that most need a few days (or weeks) of use to break in and work correctly.

Actually, the oil slick will be there regardless of skimming. Surface tension attracts the protein gunk too and can actually hold it there so your skimmer can't get to it.

Surface agitation of any kind will keep the crud dissolved in the water.

Things to consider before delving too far into the skimmer project:

What skimmer did you get?
Many small skimmers aren't really that efficient.

Does Eclipse filters have sponges n' stuff (can't remember)?
Sponge filters should be cleaned at least weekly.

How often/much are you doing water changes?
I'm guessing 3-5 gallons per week is a good starting target without a skimmer.
_________________
going green

 

[SnowManSnow]

IMO skimming is a DEFINITE plus to your tank. Some will argue against it... but in general it makes keeping a tank long term much easier. If you're worried about the LOOKS of your skimmer you may consider purchasing an external skimmer, or just install a sump via an overflow box.

It isn't very hard, and it increases your water volume which is always a plus.

B

 

[shavo]

OK I used to be a partial skimmer. I had it set up on a timer to go through the night cycle.
I never had any issues with water quality doing it that way. However i found that doing it this way that the prop in the skimmer pump would break about every 4 to 5 months. I now skim 24/7 and have not had any issues with the prop breaking apart inside the pump. just something to think about. I now have a few new props on hand just incase.

 

[Anonymous]

Skimming is never a bad idea, but remember to account for the fact that most need a few days (or weeks) of use to break in and work correctly.

Actually, the oil slick will be there regardless of skimming. Surface tension attracts the protein gunk too and can actually hold it there so your skimmer can't get to it.

Surface agitation of any kind will keep the crud dissolved in the water.

Things to consider before delving too far into the skimmer project:

What skimmer did you get?
Many small skimmers aren't really that efficient.

Does Eclipse filters have sponges n' stuff (can't remember)?
Sponge filters should be cleaned at least weekly.

How often/much are you doing water changes?
I'm guessing 3-5 gallons per week is a good starting target without a skimmer.

++1 (I agree w/ this post..)

10g is a tough size to fit an effective skimmer into.

Also, if you have to miss weekly water changes, any excess surface protein buildup can be removed by briefly laying a paper towel across the surface and quickly wicking it away. This will also allow for better oxygenation as the protein "slick" will start to inhibit gas exchange..

 

[Wingnutt021]

I try to do mini water changes every 1 or 2 days.. about a half gallon or so. I felt that would keep the most stable water conditions.

The paper towel is a good idea. I'll try that the next time I notice the slick