• Why not take a moment to introduce yourself to our members?

FathomLED

Experienced Reefer
Location
New York
Rating - 66.7%
6   3   0
First of all to all those who began as clients and are now considered our friends we thank you for all you have said on our behalf. Very early on in the thread it was stated that the OP was entitled to his opinion just as everyone else is entitled to theirs. The bottom line for us is that the client was extremely happy with his purchase and we did everything we could to ensure that. We don't think that is debatable here from the numerous testimonies about how we conduct our business practices. So we do hope that everyone sees that.
We make an earnest attempt to follow up and keep following up with all our clients not just because we are trying to earn more business and trust with the intent of slacking on customer service someday, but because we actually spent hours setting up and researching what their plans and intentions are for their tanks knowing they will care for their inhabitants just like we care for our own. Only in this way can we collect even more data to enhance our product. In all honesty in this hobby we can make our wallets bleed with the money we pull out to sustain and try to recreate what God made to the best of our ability. This is definitely not an easy task given even though there are so many knowns there are undoubtedly an equal amount or more unknown variables to contend with.

Second, we do not want to be AI, Ecotech or any other brand out there. We strive to be different. One that will show up at your door if you need a hand, while although, we have been called foolish for this, not expect anything in return. This is the hobby, the brotherhood and sisterhood, we all should be embracing, so all of our tanks benefit continuously and not just when a tragedy hits a member's tank like Sandy did. It is unfortunate how caring we are for each other only during times like this rather than displaying consistent concern when it comes to our shared passion.

That being said, we hope that justifies the feelings and enthusiasm the OP had when he posted. Much the same as people would say of their skimmers, tanks, and any other equipment they might have. He did not willfully want to start a debate yet it was thrust upon him. We are sure that if anyone is happy with their setup there is a strong chance they will defend it as well, which was shown here. But honestly where does that get us? In our opinion it just tears apart the community vs enhancing the experience.

So for the sake of the shared passion if there are questions about the fixtures or what we do here that has made our clients feel this way by all means we are here to answer. We have a large amount of testing equipment here that determines what options we present to clients and it is much more than just a PAR meter. We have a spectrometer that uses fiber optic cable to conduct readings underwater, irradiance and reflectance machinery just to name a few. A rather large investment on our part but in our eyes a crucial one. As it is not very reliable to overlay a bunch of spectrum readings in our eyes, throw a ridiculous array of LEDs on a heatsink and say "here this is the solution to all your needs, good luck".

Which finally brings us to the newest member to this discussion.....Bhazard451. Vincent, on June 19, 2012 of this year you inquired about the product and were routed to us as the exclusive distributor for your 34 gallon tank inquiry. One of the sales girls replied to you on Jun 19, 2012. In the email you stated that you had a 34 gallon mixed reef with LPS/SPS/Soft Coral , were upgrading to a 120 and the price would need to be good. You also mentioned the Razor and questioned if 420 nm violet could be added in. Our sales girl told you then back in June that the 420nm would not be Cree as they do not make that color chip yet here we are 6 months later and you are on a soapbox stated this fact. You also stated you would only want 2 violets which guess what? After testing would not have grown that one piece of sps you had any different than if the chip was not included. At that point you attempted to conduct some sort of group buy which eventually wound up with you losing your pm privileges on another forum. Whether it was because of your group buy attempts for you to gain something for yourself from us or from you ever pressing love for Evergrow and their LED filled shotgun that is spewed across a heatsink or perhaps from the stealth vending accusations. From our perspective now that you have joined in here. You are still attempting to conduct the same behavior. I am going to assume with only 7 posts you may still have your pm privileges here and can pm us anytime or if you would like and only if you can conduct yourself in a civil discussion not like that you have previously displayed on other forums we would gladly open up a page on our vendor site just for you to have all your questions answered. But for clarification purposes for those following this thread we will address your issues to date.

Your first post which it is not even worth quoting is all stated on our site as well as on our vendor page. However you really do not know the research being done here especially with the violet comment which we addressed back in June. 60 degree optics are standard by us not anyone else so you need to do a bit more research especially when customized optics are offered on everything we post. In reference to the China comment and the XTE not catching on there yet. You may possibly be under the assumption that Cree is made here and the Chinese have not embraced it yet. For that i give you this bit of info http://www.bizjournals.com/triangle/stories/2009/11/09/daily5.html so yeah it is there. Oddly enough since your main comparison was with the Razor (also from the same region) it is safe to say you are incorrect. Also most of the tanks we have worked on have been 120 gallons and over which is why we choose the 60 degree merely as a standard base point but certainly not thrust upon a client as it is all determined by their system and where they want to go with it.

Your second post attacks the OP for the optics. There are two issues here. Duke never mentions if he has 40 degree or the 70 degree so how can you make such an assumption especially when you have no idea what optics we used on the OP's tank. So therefore once again you are chasing rainbows without knowing what is going on. Merely just basing things on your vendetta towards us for some reason.

Third post you got something right, optics are not hard to swap but what you did mess up on again is that all units come here without any optics attached. Dare i say now that the unit is assembled in the US? No.

Your final post seems to make you come around a bit once you learn a little more about us and how we treat our clients. But then you have to go out and say Cree doesnt hit certain spectrum's very well. Well the truth is Cree doesn't hit 400-430 at all really in fact you were told that in June. Cree does make a red chip 620-630nm not 660 but close enough to get your algae growing and as you stated so firmly on the other site you are aware that the ww contains red. So all in all you were wrong on the other site and you are wrong here. So i would I think if nothing else you should acknowledge LowezAkar24's statement when he said " The Pharos FathomLED's are not what you think bro. The optics are not the same as the AI's" because you really don't know what optics we used and you don't know what optics Duke is using. Nor have you any clie about the research done here. SO the guy you wasted so much time bashing unecessarily ultimately turns out to be correct. So if there is an issue with us please take it up with us. You have our contact info. But it certainly was a pleasure hearing from you again. BTW did you ever get in contact with Stellarnet to purchase the equipment for testing or are you still just overlapping datasheets and risking livestock? Oh and just a last note I really don't recommend stealth vending on this forum either. Cheers.
 
Last edited:

cmantis

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 100%
103   0   0
This is why your review can't be taken seriously. If you knew any better, you'd know the optics used in the Pharos are very close beam wise to the 40 degree optics used in the AI Sol. You would also realize they use some of THE SAME leds, with the Pharos running at a higher power. If you weren't contradicting yourself, there is a good chance your coral would be dead by now.

Yo bhazard, whats up brother? I didn't know you were from NY and a member on here. You've been here longer than I but rarely post I guess.
 

cmantis

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 100%
103   0   0
I've seen this thread for a long time, I'm up to page 10......

For those just joining us, I will take the time to now take a quick break to summarize what has happened thus far.

1. OP is one hell of a happy customer who took the time to give credit to the seller, decided to share his joy in this wonderful, fun friendly:rolleyes: online environment.

2. Start of a debate. Small business LED builders vs. The Big Boys...AI Ecotech etc.

3. Things escalate.

4. WHOS BETTER??? I AM! No I AM, NO **** you my LED IS THE BEST. F*** your LED company they suck!:tank::smash::smash::tank:



Seriously.....who gives a crap who's freaking lights are better? OH! :idea: Nobody!


Opinions are like a$$holes. Everyone has one.



Have a great day everyone.

Thanks for this haven't even bothered to try to keep up just not worth it. I know Fathom and definitely great customer service but everyone is welcome to their opinion. It just sucks when it turns into bickering.
 

Nottick

Advanced Reefer
Location
Staten Island
Rating - 100%
48   0   0
I wasn't born yesturday , There is no way Richies bill is $1200.oo to run a reef tank. Thats what I was reffering to . Not making a comment on your lamps. There is no change in his tank after the leds for better or worse. Just putting the truth out there . I also ran four 400 watt m/h .

Funny you say this Greg... When was the last time you were there to see for yourself. Practice what you preach, don't believe everything you hear. Btw did you ever measure the watts consumed by a 400 watt MH ballast? Do that x4 over 12 hrs a day plus all others I think you'll be surprised.
 

greg 45

Advanced Reefer
Location
bayonne / nj
Rating - 100%
24   0   0
Nottick I have been over the house . BTW I also at one time ran 4 - 400 watt mh with 2 sets of 160 watt x 2 bulbs actinic. I also run bigger skimmers bigger return pumps than Richie . My bill for my reef isnt even close . If you want to chat pm me I will give you my number . My statment still stands of the electric bill !!!!!!!!!!!
 

Nottick

Advanced Reefer
Location
Staten Island
Rating - 100%
48   0   0
Nottick I have been over the house . BTW I also at one time ran 4 - 400 watt mh with 2 sets of 160 watt x 2 bulbs actinic. I also run bigger skimmers bigger return pumps than Richie . My bill for my reef isnt even close . If you want to chat pm me I will give you my number . My statment still stands of the electric bill !!!!!!!!!!!

No you havnt. Haha. Your making statements that hold no truth. If you want an energy calculator in excel form ill give it to ya. No one here ever claimed the tank cost 1200 month to run btw. Just said electric bill. So wipe your feet before you jump down someone's throat. K shnookums?
 

strgazr27

Advanced Reefer
Location
Kings Park, NY
Rating - 100%
123   0   0
Yeah man, I heard his other lights carried like a $1200 a month electric bill.

A 400w MH ballast draws roughly 480w. Lets multiply that times the 4 units he was running so we get 1920 watts or 1.92 Kw's.

Lets say he ran them 12 hours a day which is probably a little longer than he actually ran them but let's err on the high side. We can use an average of 30 days in a month and 12 months in a year. On Long Island we pay roughly .21 per Kw. Richie may be paying more but I will use that figure.

1.92 Kw x 12 hours x 30 days x .21/Kw = $145 per month in electric to run his MH's. Now this does not take into account his chiller but as you can see whoever told you he was paying $1200 a month in electric for his tank lights was REALLY mistaken. And as you look at the numbers I just posted you can see that we have almost $1100 to work with before we get to your stated $1200 a month. Hopefully Richie can chime in quick and clear this up.

And not everyone needs to run a chiller when running MH's. I had 2 250s over my 120 and never saw more than 81 degrees. The right reflector at the right height does wonders for controlling tank temps.

To the OP I am very happy you like your lights and look forward to your thoughts and growth/color pictures 12 months from now. Hopefully you are just as happy than. The customer service provided by Fathom is to be applauded and something all manufacturers should strive for regardless of company size. I will say that Ecotech and Neptune Systems offer some of the best customer service in the business. Hopefully these LEDs take off sales wise and the same level of customer service can be maintained.
 

rkaragozler

Newbiee 4 Ever
Location
Staten Island
Rating - 100%
125   0   0
I think it's time to put an end to this electric bill thing, I never said that my tank costs $1200 to run a month. this was my electric bill. At the time that this all came up was when I changed my lighting ovet to leds. At the time it was August, I have a 1 1/2 hp motor that runs my pool, My ac unit is over 15 years old, and not very efficient, my blower motor for my central ac is 1hp, I run 2 refrigerators, their is 4 pumps that are tied to my sytem that run 24 hours a day, 4 halides, 4 ballasts, at the time I was also running a 6 bulb t5 fixture over my 120, and a 4 bulb over my 65, not to mention the 24" 2 bulb t5 over my refugium that runs 24/7. their was 4 korallias and 2 mp60. During the summer months I also have a lot of people coming over for bbq, and it last till the wee morning, having all the lights on in the house doesn't help either. I am sure I am missing other electric items in the house.
strgazr27, you are very close to your calculations. Thank you.
here is the actual power consumption of 1 halide that I was running. 400w ushio bulb, and a 400w ice cap ballast
halideusage.jpg


And this is the consumption of 1 led unit. Both channels driven at 100 percent.
ledcomsumtion.jpg

Hope this helps this thread.
 
Last edited:

JimmyR1rider

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 100%
48   0   0
i think it's time to put an end to this electric bill thing, i never said that my tank costs $1200 to run a month. This was my electric bill. At the time that this all came up was when i changed my lighting ovet to leds. At the time it was august, i have a 1 1/2 hp motor that runs my pool, my ac unit is over 15 years old, and not very efficient, my blower motor for my central ac is 1hp, i run 2 refrigerators, their is 4 pumps that are tied to my sytem that run 24 hours a day, 4 halides, 4 ballasts, at the time i was also running a 6 bulb t5 fixture over my 120, and a 4 bulb over my 65, not to mention the 24" 2 bulb t5 over my refugium that runs 24/7. Their was 4 korallias and 2 mp60. During the summer months i also have a lot of people coming over for bbq, and it last till the wee morning, having all the lights on in the house doesn't help either. I am sure i am missing other electric items in the house.
Strgazr27, you are very close to your calculations. Thank you.
Here is the actual power consumption of 1 halide that i was running. 400w ushio bulb, and a 400w ice cap ballast
halideusage.jpg


and this is the consumption of 1 led unit. Both channels driven at 100 percent.
ledcomsumtion.jpg

hope this helps this thread.

party pooper!!! Lol.
 

Alfredo De La Fe

Senior Member
Location
Upper West Side
Rating - 100%
30   0   0
Richie, we really need to meet, I think we would get along just great. ;-) I love how you shut that particular thread down!

My wife bugs me at least once a week about shutting down my 180 because of the electric bill. As soon as I can afford it I plan on pulling out my 400W MH and having Jimmy over to install the LED's. Cutting my electric consumption by 3/4 would go a long way towards a happier wife, thus a happier me! (Plus, I won't have to sit in a sweat box during the winter or an icebox during the summer because of the A/C running 24/7 and heat output of the MH fixture!)

Alfred
 

Sponsor Reefs

We're a FREE website, and we exist because of hobbyists like YOU who help us run this community.

Click here to sponsor $10:


Top