• Why not take a moment to introduce yourself to our members?

marrone

The All Powerful OZ
Staff member
Vendor
Location
The Big City
Rating - 98.8%
80   1   0
First, only a few negative feedback have ever been remove, it needs to be very clear cut that the feedback is wrong and shouldn'the have been given in the first place. We're also not going to get involved in he said she said type of transactions, those need to be worked out among members.

As for Mods deleting their owe feedback, well that is not something that is done nor is it open for discussion on the board. Sorry but that not going to happen here so please don'the bring it up agsin.
 
Last edited:

marrone

The All Powerful OZ
Staff member
Vendor
Location
The Big City
Rating - 98.8%
80   1   0
I think what most people do is keep a list of people and deal only with them. Some people also use papal to hold items too. Both of those things do work but you do limit yourself in the number of people that you deal with.

I know that it can be frustrating when people flake out on you, but sometimes it can be legit, as family and work does come into play and sometimes people can'take respond. So before leaving negative feedback, or stop dealing with that person, please take those things into account.
 

Mrcrab125

Experienced Reefer
Location
Westchester
Rating - 100%
3   0   0
Of course not and we also will never know. Just to show how fair the system is
Dnt worry i will never bring it up again i just hope every1 will see it before it gets deleted.
Everytime a discussion is open and any1 mention this or that of the "MODS" it gets lock or deleted.
Even if is the truth.
Anyways gd luck with this. I just prefer no receive not give.
 

Mrcrab125

Experienced Reefer
Location
Westchester
Rating - 100%
3   0   0
Actually no. I got much respect for people that volunteer they time and take heat like this for no reason. I very much appreciate that
Unfortunately i have to make a point and that is asking u how would u feel if u received a "unfair" rating?? Whether u r a mod or not!!
Nothing else but to move on!! N that is unfair!!!!!
Im not gonna post anymore
And to the OP and all other members if u dnt want a bad reefer rating dont leave 1 cuz theres nothing that can be done.!!!
Happy reefing!!!!
 
C

Cu455

Guest
Rating - 100%
3   0   0
Fake rating can happen on any site amazon, yelp or Angies list. What stops people from making fake accounts and upping their feedback or a vendor making an account to bad mouth another vendor or praise themselves. There will always be a reason why something isn't fair. I think the feedback system on this site is one of the best systems I have seen. You don't have to do a search and skim through threads were everyone gives their opinion on the person. The persons feedback is posted right under their name. People are constantly seeing it and if you have a crappy rating its like wearing a scarlet letter.

I don't think revenge negative feedback is an issue. There are situations which are debatable such as who broke equipment. People might get mad for being called out. I would guess revenge feedback for flakes is far and few between.

Has anyone ever received negative feedback as retaliation were the person who left it did it purely for spite? The feedback system doesn't work because people don't give negative feedback.
 

saltwaterinbrooklyn

Pro hobby anti profit!
Location
Staten Island ny
Rating - 100%
132   0   0
Boom!! Point made now press send!! I will just shut off my pms in times of transactions and ask that all offers both fair and lowball be posted on sales thread this way we can all see the real dealers on mr!!!

And the credit for this idea goes to mbg75. .... Good idea.
 

albano

Saltwater since 1973
Staff member
Vendor
Rating - 100%
129   0   0
I will just shut off my pms in times of transactions and ask that all offers both fair and lowball be posted on sales thread this way we can all see the real dealers on mr!!!

Counter offers (lowball or not) are to be made thru PM and will be deleted if posted on FS threads.
 

edd

Advanced Reefer
Location
nj
Rating - 100%
96   0   0
I think what most people do is keep a list of people and deal only with them. Some people also use papal to hold items too. Both of those things do work but you do limit yourself in the number of people that you deal with.

I know that it can be frustrating when people flake out on you, but sometimes it can be legit, as family and work does come into play and sometimes people can'take respond. So before leaving negative feedback, or stop dealing with that person, please take those things into account.

this day in age with all the communication that people carry with them, theirs no reason for not giving a heads up, i can't make it. so we're talking irresponsible people who doesn't care about inconveniencing other people.
 

bkstang

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 100%
158   0   0
For people who say they will never leave a negative feedback:

Imagine, you got a PM from someone who wants to buy an item and is coming in 30 minutes. You are waiting even longer in spite of the fact you have something important to do. The person never shows up and doesn't communicate. Then, the same situation happens to you again with another reefer. You still don't leave any negative feedback? Chances are these people will do the same to other reefers. Aren't we here to help each other?
 

E.intheC

Advanced Reefer
Location
Suffolk County
Rating - 100%
150   0   0
For people who say they will never leave a negative feedback:

Imagine, you got a PM from someone who wants to buy an item and is coming in 30 minutes. You are waiting even longer in spite of the fact you have something important to do. The person never shows up and doesn't communicate. Then, the same situation happens to you again with another reefer. You still don't leave any negative feedback? Chances are these people will do the same to other reefers. Aren't we here to help each other?

I'm willing to bet 9x out of 10, that same person will retaliate and give you a negative rating. It sucks but that's reality. Moving forward, people will see your negative feedback and might think you're a goon.

In general, I don't have time to be worried about small stuff like this. It's a hobby. Stuff happens. A long time ago, I sold a purple tang to someone. He came by early in the morning, and the day of, right before he got there, (of course) the poor tang got ich spots on him. Zero signs of it prior to that. I told the guy that I'd give him the fish for free and apologized profusely. he could have easily given me a negative rating. Instead, he was a stand-up guy, took the fish, and promised to pay me back if the fish lived. Reluctantly, I accepted. He saved the fish, (because he's the man and knows what he's doing) and ended up paying me back later. So it worked out for everyone.

The vast majority of experiences here have been positive, though.

If you're someone who gets all worked up, then I suggest only buying new equipment and fish/corals from a store, and not selling here at all. If you NEED to sell things to stay in the hobby, you might want to rethink things. Sorry but it's the truth. The hobby is just not worth getting stressed out over.

Another quick note: ever since posting "lowballers will be listed publicly", I haven't been low-balled once. I also try dealing with people I know personally or who have a solid, chill-attitude when posting on here.
 

duke62

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 100%
224   0   0
Some of the problem is you inquire about a item via text or pm and then you decide it's not right for you. Then the person gets mad that you asked questions and didn't buy the item and then leave a negative feedback for wasting their time. Situations like that are wrong and seen it numerous times on here in someone's feedback.
 

Sponsor Reefs

We're a FREE website, and we exist because of hobbyists like YOU who help us run this community.

Click here to sponsor $10:


Top